'Music videos are simply an extension of the lyrics.' - Andrew Goodwin.
How could
you prove/disprove this theory?
In some ways, this theory is very true. Quite often the song
lyrics do tend to be similar to the music video. I therefore believe that in
order to prove or disprove this theory, I would first need to look at the lyrics
of a song without the video, and then look at the video without the song. This
would allow me to analyse whether there is similarity between them or not.
What does
it mean?
It means that music videos are somewhat unnecessary as they
do not tell the viewer anything really essential about the song, only instead
adding unnecessary extension. Andrew Goodwin therefore seems to be dismissing
music videos as being quite unnecessary and pointless.
What is the
main idea behind this?
Goodwin seems to believe that music videos are somewhat
unnecessary as they do not add anything important or really different to the
song.
How
significant is this?
I find it to be significant to some extent. Some music videos
do seem to just simply extend the lyrics, without providing anything new or
important to the song. This will therefore be something that I will need to consider
when making my own music video, to ensure that it is interesting.
What
evidence can you already present for this?
One song that strongly fulfils this theory is Michael Jackson’s
‘Thriller’, where the lyrics are very clearly extended through a film-like
sequence.
Also, in the Taylor Swift song ‘You Belong With Me’, she is
shown to be a girl who wants a boy to realise that ‘he belongs with her’, which
does little more than expanding upon the pre-existing lyrics.
Do you
agree with this? Explain your answer.
To an extent, I do agree with the statement. Some music
videos such as the examples that I have highlighted above do exactly what
Goodwin says, and seem to do little else than extend the lyrics. I also believe
that this is more typical in some genres than others, as Pop follow this theory
rather explicitly whereas other genres such as Indie tend to use more quirky
and abstract videos, which perhaps follow a more metaphorical than literal
route. The artists are also able to tell the story that they want and expand
upon the lyrics through a video, as Stuart Hall would call a preferred reading.
However, I also believe that sometimes music videos are really important. In
Mcfly’s ‘Love is Easy’, the viewer is able to go on a ‘journey’ through the time
that Mcfly had been together for, with just some elements that may perhaps
reflect the lyrics. I overall do agree quite a lot with Goodwin’s statement but
nevertheless believe music videos to be of the upmost importance.
I have learnt from this task that it is really important to consider theories when I am planning and making my music video, This will ensure that it is conventional, which will be an important factor for it to be a success.